Top Female Driven Superhero Books-Just Good In Comparison?

I take reviews with a grain of salt. Seeing as I use a mail order system I’m issues ahead in books before they arrive and the discussions start. I usually ignore these discussions but when you cruise sites like I do you get the jist of what people are saying. Some of what people are saying about the new X-Men book is that its next best book on the market. I did run into a bad review and I positively believe all material needs bad reviews but I can already see the lovers of the book disregarding a different opinion. If you don’t like this female driven book thats gotten high marks you must be wrong. Right? No, fuck that.

X-Men #1, from an objective stand point, has a thin set up. John Sublime is following Jubilee who is carrying a baby. By the time you hit the end you may already know what the reason is, if not, you will not be impressed. What works about X-Men #1 is first and foremost the art. Its excellent. Followed by Jubilee herself, she shines. The other characters have a few moments but only 20 pages and having to introduce the plot set up and a cast of six plus Sublime leaves little time to give everyone a scene. It’s a fine book, it just did not leave an impression on me. Better than the low review I saw but nowhere near 5 stars. This of course is my feelings about it and its obvious there are fans who are praising this book greatly at the moment. Hey, thats cool but is it really that good or is it just good in comparison?

I feel at times that all it takes to get excellent reviews on a female driven title is to have non exploitive art and well rounded female characters. That the plot itself, the way the story is executed, can take a back seat. Or in some cases, the stories fine but the art is bland-not bad just not frustrating for a certain audience so they keep behind it. That few of these books really hit all the notes, there is always something major off but it gets a pass where if it was a different title it wouldn’t.

Batwoman is a book that has deep characters, though I do not care fore Kate Kane and the book has made me lose my love of Cameron Chase, there is no doubt the writers are working on complex and rich characters. The art has been fantastic. I include Amy Reeder in that, she is awesome. The stories themselves have felt lackluster to me. When I think of Batwoman, I think of visuals and thats all. Its beautiful and it eclipses the story itself. This is how I feel. When I read great reviews for Fearless Defenders sometimes it seems they talk about everything but the Will Slinely art. Thats not to say I’m the only one who feels this way. I’ve noticed in the last few months the praise for Batwoman has died down and I’ve talked to some fans who feel they would enjoy Defenders more with Slinely replaced.

I don’t want to sound like a drag, I’m very much a ‘like what like kind of guy.’ I’m also the kind of guy who looks past the flaws in material to enjoy it. Though usually that material is considered general bad (or heavily mixed reviews). Still, I’m not trashing on the books I just feel the heavy praise of some of these books ignores certain flaws that stick out.

Now, going back to the debut X-Men issue, its one issue in. I am already ordered up to issue 3 at least. Maybe 4 by the time I get issue 2. Its entirely possible the second issue will knock it out the park. I can be back saying, “Okay, they were right.” I really do want to get back to reading X-Men books with Rogue. However, if I was back at a comic shop I would question picking up issue 2. I know, I know, you should always give a book a few issues. But you notice people only say that about the titles they like? If I told you to give Winick and March’s Catwoman a few issues I’d have a rock thrown at me by some ladies. Not all the ladies though.

And yes, I liked Catwoman. I find complete reckless abandon, style over substance and craziness in mainstream superhero comics fascinating and entertaining.

Advertisements

About CM Towns

I like comics, wrestling, and other junk.
This entry was posted in comic books, dc comics, female superheroes, marvel comics, superhero and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Top Female Driven Superhero Books-Just Good In Comparison?

  1. xmenxpert says:

    I loved X-Men #1. Part of it is that I loved Brian Wood’s previous X-Men run, which had an interesting story, excellent character dynamics, and some great action. So I have a lot of trust in Wood. And Coipel’s a great artist. And the team is made up of great characters. Pretty much everything about this book is designed to make me interested. I don’t think this will be a great female-driven series. I think it’s going to be a great series.

    In terms of Fearless Defenders, Sliney’s art doesn’t generally bother me. It’s probably not the right fit – it could use someone more like Valerio Schitti, perhaps, something a little less conventional – but most of the time, it’s fine, and after some cheesecake in the first issue, it’s been remarkably free of any sort of sexualization of the women.

    Interestingly, two more of my favourite titles right now are also female-led: Captain Marvel and Journey Into Mystery, which are both also written by women. They’re both great, character-focused books. I don’t know if you read The Enemy Within #1, but DeConnick did an amazing job showing the close friendship between Carol and Jessica. It was one of the best friendship scenes I’ve ever read in a comic, and it was absolutely wonderful.

    • CM Towns says:

      I admit that my past reading of Brian Wood leave no strong impression. I read DMZ for years just to realize I couldn’t remember the names of the leads. My problem with X-Men #1 is the set up is not really surprising. Once you read the beginning the ending is obvious and other than Jubilee the other characters have little time to shine. Plus I’ve been out of the loop so John Sublime does not remind me of the character from new X-Men.

      Slinely’s art doesn’t bother me but I find it keeps it from being the 5 star book some people think of it as. I don’t care for it.

      I don’t like Carol Danvers. Everything I read previously turned me off, I have not checked out Journey into Mystery. Most the female driven books I’m reading now are on the indy scene or from Vertigo.

      I just felt disappointed by X-Men, as I have from Batwoman and a few others. I love female characters but right now I’m not into what Marvel and DC are selling really. I read these books and there is something that turns me off, or something I find bland and uninteresting.

      Thats just my feelings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s